IPO vs Direct Listing: Knowing the Difference

Timothy has helped provide CEOs and CFOs with deep-dive analytics, providing beautiful stories behind the numbers, graphs, and financial models. From equities, fixed income to derivatives, the CMSA certification bridges the gap from where you are now to where you want to be — a world-class capital markets analyst. The material provided on this website is for information purposes only and should not be understood as an investment advice. Any opinion that may be provided on this page does not constitute a recommendation by Capital Com or its agents. We do not make any representations or warranty on the accuracy or completeness of the information that is provided on this page.

This happens through a single order, which is executed as part of the opening auction. In today’s world, businesses need even more flexibility and transparency to meet evolving customer, talent and market demands. Going public is a powerfully effective solution to meet those needs but companies no longer need to view an IPO as their only path to public. Subject to compliance with federal and state securities laws, a company may sell its shares to the public using a variety of methods.

However, there are key differences between the two that you’ll want to be aware of as an investor. An IPO, which is more common, is when a company creates and underwrites new shares and then sells them to the public. A direct listing, on the other hand, involves listing only existing shares and, therefore, doesn’t require any underwriting.

Frequently asked IPO, direct listing, and SPAC questions

It can occur for a variety of reasons, including non-compliance with listing rules or norms, mergers, or bankruptcy. UnderwritersThe underwriters take the financial risk of their client in return of a financial fee. Market Makers like financial institution and large banks ensure that there is enough amount of liquidity in the market by ensuring that enough trading volume is there.

In 2021, Salesforce acquired Slack for $27.7 billion, ultimately absorbing WORK https://forex-world.net/ under its own publicly traded moniker. Thus, the difference between IPO and share’s direct listing is influential in the listing decision of companies going public and the investments made by share buyers. In a direct listing, the company is not required to involve any intermediaries to sell their existing stocks. The slack stock opened at$38.50per share, up 48% from the reference price of $26 per share on its public debut on the New York Stock Exchange .

• Inform and educate employees that they can’t sell immediately and will have to adhere to lockup periods that are often 90 days long.
• The company then must determine how much it will list shares for on the exchange.
• Shares began at €82.50 each, reaching a peak of €86.78 before finally settling at €85.50.
• Companies that can’t afford underwriting, don’t want share dilution, or are avoiding lockup periods often choose the direct listing process, a less-expensive option than an IPO.
• This could be a lack of guarantee for share sales and the fact that there are no safe long-term investors.

The most commonly used exemptions are for intrastate offerings, offerings under $1 million , and Regulation A. In such cases, state level registration is generally required. State level registration is usually less onerous and time-consuming than federal registration. Charitable organizations are also exempt from registration with the SEC and in most states. ] is a method by which a company can offer an investment opportunity directly to the public. Guest and Partner at Latham and Watkins, Ben Cohen explains, employees get liquidity on the first day of trading, which acts as an amazing boost for employee engagement. Although direct listings could be considered easier in terms of what’s involved, it’s still a complex topic.

Direct Listing vs. IPO: 8 Things to Know

As a global financial services firm, Morgan Stanley is committed to technological innovation. We rely on our technologists around the world to create leading-edge, secure platforms for all our businesses. We offer scalable investment products, foster innovative solutions and provide actionable insights across sustainability issues.

The underwriter will also go on a roadshow to create excitement and help establish a public market for the shares, eventually culminating in the final price for the IPO. Direct listings and IPOs are different, and some companies may be better off using one or the other when going public. The rule tends to be that direct listings are better for companies that have solid brand recognition, but don’t have a dire need to raise capital. IPOs, conversely, are better for the majority of companies, particularly those looking to raise capital or lock in a pool of investors. Both an IPO and a direct listing are ways for a company to make its shares available for public purchase via a stock exchange. IPOs are the more common choice, especially for larger companies that have the means to work with an underwriter.

The promoters of the target company may be in a position to negotiate a premium valuation as the deal has to be completed within a specific time frame. If well-known executives back the SPAC, the target company may benefit from an experienced team and improved market visibility. Below, we share eight things you should know as you consider which path is best for your company. The opening auctions that sit at the heart of pricing Direct Listings are sizable and complex transactions. The NYSE’s unique market model, built on the fact that stocks trade best when human oversight and accountability are integrated with world class technology, allows us to flawlessly execute such transactions. The NYSE is the only exchange to provide a Designated Market Maker to minimize volatility and discover market demand price assessment with unparalleled precision.

A direct public offering is a simpler way for a company to go public than a traditional initial public offering . While it’s a relatively low-cost process, going public via a DLP carries certain risks. As there is no road show, investor sentiment might be subdued, resulting in tepid demand for the company’s shares. In addition, no underwriter guarantees the sale of shares, and there may also be lesser participation from institutional investors, which might increase the volatility of share prices after the listing.

IPOs are usually subject to a holding period whereby investors that bought shares are not able to sell them for a given time. A SPAC goes public as a shell company using an IPO for the purpose of merging with or acquiring a yet-to-be-identified private operating company. The transaction costs, including underwriter fees, are high, and the process typically takes a long time. The dilutive impact is kept to a minimum in a direct listing since no new capital is raised – albeit new regulations have changed the rules regarding new capital raising. The trend of direct listings is anticipated to persist, especially considering the number of well-capitalized start-ups that will soon be going public. Financial and legal info is available to all investors in the company’s prospectus on Form S-1, before and after the actual stock offering.

Direct Listing

The risk to companies seeking a capital raise through a direct listing may be dramatically lower as a result of the Nasdaq and New York Stock Exchange updating their DL rules at the end of 2022. The new rules could expand the options for companies that want to go public. There’s also no lockup period, which means existing shareholders can maintain liquidity and motivate price action. Once a company goes public through a direct listing, that stock is available to the general public on the stock market.

• This material is not intended as a recommendation, offer, or solicitation to purchase or sell securities, open a brokerage account, or engage in any investment strategy.
• A DPO is similar to an initial public offering in that securities, such as stock or debt, are sold to investors.
• While companies that choose IPOs must pay for the services of underwriters, they also receive support from investment banks to market stock and drive sales.
• The subscription model for software has taken capital expenditure and made it operating expenditure and they don’t need the same level of infrastructure with the advent of public cloud computing technology.
• From an investor’s perspective – particularly long-term investors – the health and prospects of the underlying company are more important than the method used to go public.
• Founded in 1976, Bankrate has a long track record of helping people make smart financial choices.

Investors need to consider their risk-reward profile before investing in an IPO, SPAC, or direct listing. Further, analysts and investors should look at tax rates, the average beta, the weighted average cost of capital , and debt-to-equity multiples. The WACC provides a discount rate used to discount the company’s future cash flows, allowing you to arrive at a fair valuation. For those looking to raise capital and create brand awareness by engaging with their investor base, IPOs are a good bet.

Linking ESG performance metrics to your employee equity plans

The direct listing process, also known as a direct public offering or direct placement, does not involve the services of an underwriter or the creation of any new shares. This can be better suited for companies that don’t have the funds to pay for an underwriter or don’t want to dilute their existing shares. An underwriter is an intermediary that works closely with the company during the IPO process and charges a commission for its services. Nasdaq received approval in December from the SEC for its proposal to ease its direct listing rules.

You could buy it the first day it trades and face immediate pressure from heavily invested insiders who are trying to sell the shares they held going into the first day of trading. You might argue that this is a more fair form of trading, and you wouldn’t have the end of the lockup period hanging over you, as you would with an IPO. Discounted cash flow, or DCF, is a highly detailed and comprehensive evaluation method.

SPACs are also known as blank check companies because the target company is unknown to investors at the time of the IPO. A private company becomes public, typically without raising new funds in the process, by allowing existing shareholders to sell shares directly to the public. A future challenge is that people are still trying to understand the behavior of both sellers and buyers in this process and the effects of unfettered liquidity on trading. Public investors have noticed how highly liquid the two direct listings have been.

Aditya Raghunath is a financial journalist who writes about business, public equities, and personal finance. His work has been published on several digital platforms in the U.S. and Canada, including The Motley Fool, Finscreener and Market Realist. With a post-graduate degree in finance, Aditya has close to 8 years of work experience in financial services and close to six years in producing financial content. Aditya’s area of expertise includes evaluating stocks in the tech and cannabis sectors.

Research shows that in the past decade, VC-backed IPOs underwritten by Goldman Sachs had, on average, a 33.8 per cent first-day gain. Some VCs now believe it’s hard to justify giving away millions of dollars in one day. This means in the battle of direct listings vs IPOs, we could start to see a new champion emerging.

If you are considering investing in the stock market, he recommends reading The Intelligent Investor by Benjamin Graham before taking the plunge. Analysts can also include several companies in the same sector, and calculate the averages of their valuation multiples to see if the private company is reasonably valued relative to its publicly traded peers. The Direct Listing provides access and opportunity for all investors, democratizing public company offerings even further than before. If you’re doing an direct listing or IPO, consider creating a written FAQ about timing, lockup periods, and other relevant guidelines. Inform and educate employees that they can’t sell immediately and will have to adhere to lockup periods that are often 90 days long. It’s imperative to let employees know what they can and can’t do, how long they’ll have to wait before selling, and why those rules are in place.

How we make money

Since new Direct listing vs ipo are sold to the public, an IPO often dilutes the ownership share of existing investors in the company. On November 26, 2019, the NYSE laid the groundwork with an SEC filing to allow listed companies to raise capital and go public through a direct listing. A company looking to raise interest-free capital from the public by listing its shares has two options—an IPO or a direct listing. Unlike an IPO in which the share price is negotiated beforehand, in a direct listing the price of the stock depends solely on supply and demand. This increases volatility, as the range in which the stock is traded is less predictable.

It’s easier to value mature businesses that generate steady and predictable sales and profits and have extended operating histories. Companies planning a direct listing must also file an S-1 form with the SEC. The number of companies going public via SPACs rose to 613 in 2021, up from 247 in 2020 and 59 in 2019. Slack, Roblox, and Spotify, listed on the NYSE, ranked among the largest opening trades in the history of the US markets.

The day before trading begins, the exchange posts a “reference” price, which is based on the company’s public financial information, previous private market valuations, and the value of the company’s public competitors. On the first day of trading, the auction begins and the price can change depending on demand and other factors. DPOs are a relatively new phenomenon that offers certain advantages for companies, including a chance to save money going public . But these vehicles also pose unique risks for investors compared to traditional IPOs because they provide less information about the company’s finances and present the chance for more volatile trading. In a traditional IPO, the price of newly listed stock can sometimes rise on the first day of trading above the price agreed between the issuer and the underwriters.